<img alt="" src="https://secure.easy0bark.com/260152.png" style="display:none;">

How to Adapt Your Leadership Style to Different Employees

Have you ever given two employees the same direction and watched them respond completely differently? One takes the direction and runs with it. The other needs more context, more discussion, or more support.

It's easy to assume one of them simply isn't responding the way they should. But what if the problem isn't the person? What if your approach needs to change?

As a leader, it's natural to communicate the way you'd want someone to communicate with you. You provide the kind of support you'd appreciate, explain things the way you prefer, and expect people to respond similarly.

But people aren't all motivated by the same things. And they don't all need the same things from their leader.

Why the same leadership approach doesn't work for everyone

When leaders use the same approach with everyone, they can miss what individual employees actually need to succeed.

Consider a few examples:

  • One employee might thrive with autonomy and the freedom to make decisions.
  • Another might need clearer expectations before getting started.
  • Someone else might value regular feedback or more context before making a decision.

These differences don't necessarily reflect ability or commitment. They may simply reflect what each person needs to do their best work.

When leaders assume everyone needs the same thing, they can misinterpret an employee's response as a performance or attitude problem.

But sometimes, the issue is a mismatch between what the leader is providing and what the employee needs.

Two employees, one responsibility

Imagine a manager gives two employees the same new responsibility.

They explain what needs to be done and give both people plenty of freedom to figure out how to do it.

One employee is energized by the autonomy. They get started right away and check in when they need help.

The other employee seems hesitant. They ask a lot of questions and aren't moving forward with the same confidence.

The manager might assume the second employee isn't ready for the responsibility.

But what if the manager takes a different approach?

Instead of asking, "Why aren't they responding like the other employee?" the manager asks, "What do they need from me to be successful?"

Maybe the employee needs clearer expectations. Maybe they need to understand why the work matters. Or perhaps they need more frequent check-ins while they're building confidence.

The responsibility hasn't changed. But the leader's approach has.

And that can make the difference between someone struggling and someone succeeding.

How to adapt your leadership approach

Adapting your leadership style starts with understanding the people you're leading. Rather than assuming everyone responds the same way, pay attention to what helps each person do their best work.

Here are three ways to put that into practice.

1. Understand what motivates individual employees

People are motivated by different things. Some value independence and the opportunity to take ownership. Others are motivated by collaboration, recognition, learning, or having a clear understanding of expectations.

Take the time to understand what matters to each person rather than assuming what works for you will work for them.

2. Pay attention to the support people need

Not everyone needs the same level or type of support.

One employee may be comfortable taking an assignment and running with it. Another may benefit from additional context, clearer direction, or more frequent feedback.

Pay attention to how people respond and be willing to adjust your approach when something isn't working.

3. Maintain expectations while adapting your approach

Adapting your leadership style doesn't mean lowering expectations or creating a different set of rules for everyone.

The goal is to help each person meet the same expectations by providing the support, direction, and communication they need to succeed.

Fair leadership isn't necessarily identical leadership. It's understanding what people need while maintaining clarity and accountability.

Effective leadership starts with understanding people

The Golden Rule tells us to treat others the way we want to be treated, but the Platinum Rule takes that a step further: treat others the way they want to be treated.

Great leaders understand that adapting their approach isn't about lowering expectations or creating different rules for different people. It's about understanding what each person needs to succeed and providing the support that helps them meet those expectations and do their best work.

Effective leadership isn't about treating people the way you want to be treated; it's about understanding how they need to be led.

A question for leaders to consider:

Are you leading your employees the way they need to be led, or the way you would want to be led?

 

 

 

Download: 8 Things Great Leaders Do

Great leadership isn’t just about knowing what to do. It’s about how you put it into practice.

Download our free guide, 8 Things Great Leaders Do. It shares insights from Vivo Team’s coaches and eight practical behaviours that can help you strengthen your leadership.

Because when you invest in your people, the results follow.

 

 

Full Video Transcript

Have you ever had two employees hear the same message from you and respond completely differently?

One takes the direction and runs with it.

The other needs more context, more detail, more discussion, or more support.

It can be tempting to think that one of them just isn't responding the way they should.

But what if the problem isn't the person?

What if the approach needs to change?

I'm Renée Safrata, and as leaders, it's easy to assume that what works for us should work for everyone else.

We communicate the way we'd like someone to communicate with us.

We give people the kind of support we want, and we expect them to respond the way we would.

But people aren't motivated by the same things, and they don't all need the same things from their leader.

When leaders use the same approach for everyone, they can miss what individual employees actually need to succeed.

One person might want more autonomy. Another might need clearer expectations.

Someone else might need regular feedback or more context before making a decision.

If the leader assumes that everyone needs the same thing, they may interpret a different response as a performance or attitude problem.

But sometimes the issue is simply a mismatch between what the leader is providing and what the employee actually needs.

Imagine this: a manager gives two employees the same new responsibility.

They tell both people what needs to be done, give them plenty of freedom to figure it out, and let them get on with it.

One employee is energized by the autonomy. They get started right away and check in when they need help, while the other employee seems rather hesitant.

They ask a lot of questions, and they aren't moving forward with the same confidence.

The manager might assume the second employee isn't ready for the responsibility. But what if they take a different approach?

Instead of asking, "Why aren't you responding like the other employee?" the manager asks, "What do you need from me to be successful?"

Maybe the employee needs clear expectations.

Maybe they need to understand why the work matters.

Or maybe they simply need more frequent check-ins to build confidence.

The responsibility hasn't changed, but the leader's approach has, and that's the important thing.

That can make the difference between someone struggling and someone succeeding.

Great leaders don't treat everyone the same way.

They take the time to understand what matters to the people they're leading and what they need to succeed.

That doesn't mean lowering expectations or creating a different set of rules for everyone.

It means recognizing that people may need different kinds of support to meet those expectations. Because effective leadership isn't about treating people the way you want to be treated. It's about understanding how they need to be led.

So here's a question to consider.

Are you leading your employees the way you want to be led, or the way they need to be led?

Great leadership isn't about knowing what to do.

It's about how you put things into practice.

Download Vivo Team's free guide, 8 Things Great Leaders Do, in the link below.

It shares insights from Vivo Team's coaches and eight practical behaviors that can help strengthen your leadership.

Because when you invest in your people, the results will follow.